SPF (Sender Policy Framework) and DMARC (Domain-based Message Authentication, Reporting, and Conformance) are extensions to Internet email that help prevent unauthorized individuals from using your email address.

With SPF, you can significantly reduce the risk of falling victim to email-based attacks such as phishing, spoofing, and malware distribution. Read on to learn more.

Don’t compromise email security – safeguard your business and stakeholders with InboxAlly today! Learn more about InboxAlly here.

What is SPF?

SPF serves as an email authentication method designed to specify the authorized mail servers permitted to send emails on behalf of a specific domain.

By implementing this validation mechanism, Internet Service Providers (ISPs) can effectively detect and thwart attempts by spoofers and phishers to fabricate emails purportedly originating from your domain, intending to deliver malicious content to your recipients.

With SPF in place, recipients can be confident in the authenticity of the emails they receive, ensuring they originate from the expected sources.

Simultaneously, senders can enjoy peace of mind, knowing that their brand and audience are safeguarded against fraudulent practices like email spoofing and phishing attempts perpetrated by phishers.

Person using a laptop, encountering an SPF failure

What Does SPF Fail Mean? 

When an SPF authentication check yields a “fail” result, it indicates that the IP address from which the email originated is not listed as a permitted sender in the domain’s SPF record.

In essence, a valid SPF record exists, outlining the authorized mail servers that can send emails on behalf of the domain. However, the sender’s IP address does not match these authorized servers.

Consequently, an SPF failure occurs, suggesting that the email might be spoofed or sent from an unauthorized source, potentially raising suspicions of phishing or other malicious activities.

Common Reasons Why SPF Authentication Fails

1. Missing SPF Record

An SPF record is crucial for verifying the legitimacy of email senders. If a domain lacks an SPF record, receiving mail servers have no policy to reference during authentication. As a result, emails from this domain might fail SPF authentication checks, leading to potential delivery issues or being flagged as suspicious.

2. Multiple SPF Records

Having multiple SPF records for a single domain can lead to SPF authentication failures. Multiple SPF records can confuse receiving servers, as they’re unsure which record to consider. This ambiguity often results in SPF failures, as the receiving server may not interpret the intended policy correctly.

3. Excess DNS Lookups

SPF mechanisms often involve DNS lookups to retrieve information about authorized mail servers. However, excessive DNS lookups due to numerous mechanisms or nested lookups can exceed SPF’s limit on DNS queries. When this happens, SPF authentication fails, as the receiving server cannot process all the necessary DNS queries within the allowed limit.

Also Read: SPF Limit: It’s Not as Difficult as You Think

4. Syntax Errors

Syntax errors within SPF records can cause SPF authentication failures. Incorrectly formatted SPF records, such as missing or misplaced characters, invalid syntax in mechanisms or modifiers, or typographical errors, can result in SPF authentication errors.

Ensuring SPF records adhere to the correct syntax is essential to avoid authentication failures.

Related: Mastering SPF Syntax: A Step-by-Step Guide

5. Exceeding SPF Character Limits

SPF specifications limit the number of characters allowed within an SPF record. Exceeding these limits, often due to overly complex policies or many mechanisms, can lead to SPF authentication failures.

Keeping SPF records concise and within the specified character limits helps prevent authentication issues.

6. Invalid Macros

SPF records may utilize macros to dynamically include information such as the sender’s IP address or domain. However, using invalid macros or incorrectly implementing them within the SPF record can result in SPF authentication failures. To avoid authentication issues, it’s crucial to ensure macros are correctly defined and utilized according to SPF specifications.

Types of SPF Fail Qualifiers

Image of a laptop with "email marketing" content, emphasizing the importance of SPFCourtesy of Canva/LightField Studios

  • Neutral

In the context of SPF (Sender Policy Framework), a ” neutral ” result indicates that the SPF record neither explicitly authorizes nor rejects the sending server.

It signifies that the SPF check did not produce a definitive result regarding whether the email should be accepted or rejected based on SPF authentication.

MTAs (Mail Transfer Agents) encountering a “neutral” result may proceed with the email handling according to their local policies, including accepting the email or subjecting it to further scrutiny.

  • Pass

When an SPF record indicates a “pass,” the email has successfully passed SPF authentication. This implies that the sender’s IP address aligns with the SPF policy defined for the domain, indicating that the email is likely legitimate.

MTAs receiving emails with a “pass” result typically allow them to proceed without additional scrutiny, considering them trustworthy based on SPF verification.

  • Hard Fail

A “hard fail” in SPF (Sender Policy Framework) signifies that if an email fails SPF authentication, the MTA (Mail Transfer Agent) must outright reject it.

The email is not accepted into the recipient’s inbox, failing to meet the specified SPF criteria. This strict approach ensures that only emails passing SPF authentication are delivered, minimizing the risk of spoofed or fraudulent messages.

  • Soft Fail

Using the “~all” mechanism in the SPF record signifies that if an email doesn’t pass SPF authentication, the MTA is instructed to accept it but flag it as potentially suspicious. Instead of outright rejection, the email is handled with care.

SPF soft fail enables the sender to receive notifications about SPF authentication failures without triggering immediate delivery problems.

  • SPF Temperror

SPF Temperror is a temporary glitch in SPF authentication, often caused by DNS issues like timeouts. It results in a temporary failure, with the SMTP command returning a 4xx status code.

Depending on the Retry Policy, the email client-server may retry delivery without DNS operator intervention. DMARC doesn’t see SPF Temperror as significant, so the email is temporarily deferred and could be delivered later.

  • SPF Permerror

A permerror occurs when there’s a syntax error, unsupported mechanism, or other critical misconfiguration in the SPF or DMARC record. This error is considered permanent because manual intervention is required to correct the configuration issue before authentication can proceed.

For SPF, a permerror might result from syntax errors in the SPF record, unsupported mechanisms, or exceeding the DNS lookup limit.

Dealing with permerror typically involves carefully reviewing and correcting the configuration of the SPF or DMARC record to ensure it adheres to the specifications and resolves any syntax or configuration issues.

How to Fix SPF Failure For Better Email Authentication

Person working on computers, troubleshooting an SPF failure to improve email authentication.

To resolve SPF validation errors, domain owners can follow these straightforward steps:

  1. Verify and Correct the Sender’s SPF Record: 

While SPF validation errors manifest at the recipient’s end, rectification must occur on the sender’s side. Thus, reviewing the sender’s SPF records is imperative to ensure accurate configuration.

Various online tools facilitate SPF checks, confirming whether emails originate from the specified IP address in the SPF record. Any discrepancies may result in email rejection by the receiving mail server.

  1. Validate Sender’s Identity: 

Domain owners should guarantee that their emails originate from a legitimate sender. Key checks include ensuring the “from” field employs the correct domain, confirming domain and mail records directly to the accurate server, and verifying the correctness of SPF records for the domain.

By rectifying these parameters, recipients can authenticate the sender’s legitimacy and accept the email without issues.

SPF Failure – FAQS

Does SPF failure always indicate malicious activity?

Not necessarily. While SPF failure can sometimes indicate malicious activity, it can also occur for innocent reasons, such as misconfiguration or legitimate email forwarding practices. However, it’s essential to investigate and address SPF failures promptly to maintain email security.

How does SPF failure affect email deliverability rates? 

Failed SPF authentication can harm email deliverability rates. Emails that fail SPF checks are more likely to be filtered out as spam by recipient mail servers, which can reduce the effectiveness of email marketing campaigns and communication efforts.

How often should I review my SPF records? 

Regularly reviewing and updating SPF records is recommended, especially when changing mail server configurations or adding new mail services. Regular reviews help ensure that SPF records accurately reflect authorized mail servers and minimize the risk of SPF failure.

Are there any tools to help diagnose SPF issues? 

Yes, several tools, such as SPF validators or SPF record checkers, are available online to help diagnose SPF issues. These tools can analyze SPF records, verify DNS configurations, and identify potential problems causing SPF failure.

Ready to take your email security and deliverability to the next level? InboxAlly can help! Book a live demo today.